Bruce Schneier (of Counterpane Systems) has a good say about the current goings-on in the airline security world in his latest Crypto-Gram newsletter.
In short: This is theater that has no real effect on our security. This is to make you feel good, not actually do anything.
He also links to a well circulated post from the Interesting People list on the implausibility of the explosives threat. This rings true based on my experiences with organic explosives and ketone reactions – but the person posting this knows far more about these things than I do. I used to have an amatuer interest in explosives, but quit while I still had all of my fingers.
Now the rumors are that they will ban all laptops on planes – for your safety. I guess that means I’m done flying – well, if that occurs. It hasn’t yet. At this time you only have to check your laptop if you are flying between Great Britain and the US… which means I won’t be flying between Great Britain and the US. Sorry to disappoint the baggage thieves union, but I won’t be checking my $2,000 laptop in my (mandatory) unlocked luggage only to be told later, once the theft is discovered, that no one accepts fault for this.
Actually, the point isn’t the equipment. I have backups. I can insure the laptop. I’m sure I can even get work to pay for that insurance. The point is that, for me, the laptop is the point of the trip. It is the tool I use to do my job. It’s kind of like you’re going to build a house and once you get there you discover your toolbox has been stolen – the toolbox that had unique, one-of-a-kind tools necessary to finish building this house. Without these tools there is no point in the trip – and by the time you are there it is too late to replace them. The tools are the trip.
I can’t imagine how cranky I would be after sitting on a crowded plane for 10 hours only to discover that the point of the trip has been stolen, and all I have to look forward to is another 10 hour trip so I can fill out insurance forms and then look forward to another miserable trip.
But, let’s be optimistic. Maybe your laptop won’t be stolen. Maybe it will only be smashed. Here is a little article discussing just that, and how to avoid it.
Me? I’ll drive, thanks.
P.S.: TSA? Hello? Yeah, if lithium batteries are THAT dangerous you’d better make sure you ban all cell phones, iPods and watches. I’d mention pacemakers, but I’m afraid you’d take me seriously.